AARP Insurance: A Comprehensive Review and Cautionary Advice


Disclosure: We receive advertising revenue from some partners. Learn More


Navigating the world of car insurance can be a daunting task, filled with a plethora of choices and decisions. AARP Insurance, a service tailored specifically for those over 50, is a familiar name in the industry, often touted for its senior-friendly policies and benefits. But as we’ve learned in the world of car insurance, not all that glitters is gold.

AARP Insurance: A Comprehensive Review and Cautionary Advice 1

When assessing an insurance company, it’s crucial to cut through the marketing gloss and find out the real story. A quick look at the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and Trustpilot reviews for AARP Insurance reveals a somewhat mixed bag, ranging from satisfied customers praising the company’s customer service to disgruntled clients airing their grievances about claim issues and sudden rate increases.

Indeed, the insurance industry can be as murky and filled with controversies as the plot of a classic film noir. With promises of gold-standard services and coverage, companies like AARP Insurance often portray an image of reliability and trust. But beneath this shiny veneer, there could be a lurking reality of unmet claims, high costs, and frustrated customers – elements that bring to mind the twists and turns of a suspenseful movie plot.

In this review, we will critically examine AARP Insurance, casting a skeptical eye over its practices and policies. Like the hardboiled detective in our noir film, we will look beyond the surface, searching for the truth behind the claims and ratings. Whether you’re an AARP member or considering becoming one, it’s time to take a closer look at what this insurance giant has to offer and whether it stands up to scrutiny. Let’s delve into the world of AARP Insurance – where reality might not quite match the carefully crafted image.

Company Background

AARP Insurance, also known as the American Association of Retired Persons, is an interest group aimed at helping people above the age of 50 improve their quality of life. Founded in 1958 by Ethel Percy Andrus, a retired high school principal, AARP has grown significantly and today boasts a membership of nearly 38 million.

One of the primary services offered by AARP is its range of insurance products, including auto insurance, which is underwritten by The Hartford, an insurance company with its roots dating back to 1810. The alliance between AARP and The Hartford was forged in 1984, aiming to provide excellent auto insurance products to older drivers, a segment of the population often overlooked by other insurers.

Are you overpaying for car insurance?

Discover the

Rates as low as $29/month

However, despite its strong foundation and ambitious goals, AARP Insurance has been under the microscope for various reasons. A number of customers have raised concerns about steep premium hikes without prior notice, discrepancies in policy terms, and dissatisfaction with the claim settlement process. These real-life experiences echo the suspenseful scenes from the movie ‘Crash,’ where everything seems under control until chaos suddenly ensues.

The insurance company also faces criticism for its alleged aggressive marketing tactics to the elderly, akin to the plot of ‘The Wolf of Wall Street,’ where the main characters are depicted exploiting their clients for their personal gains. In 2008, AARP faced a congressional investigation over its insurance practices, with specific focus on whether the group was acting more as an insurance company than an advocate for the elderly. This investigation did little to enhance AARP Insurance’s credibility in the public eye.

program from the hartford intellectual property

Despite these controversies, AARP Insurance continues to be a significant player in the auto insurance industry. Its partnership with The Hartford allows it to offer specialized services for older adults, which includes RecoverCare, a program that assists with everyday tasks if you’re injured in an accident, and lifetime car repair assurance.

In conclusion, AARP Insurance has a rich history and a strong presence in the insurance marketplace. However, the company’s past controversies and ongoing customer complaints suggest that there is a darker side to this seemingly beneficial organization. Like the plot of a dramatic movie, the company’s story is filled with ups and downs, promising beginnings, and questionable practices, leaving customers to wonder if they’re getting a blockbuster deal or a box office flop.


AARP Insurance, underwritten by The Hartford, offers a wide range of car insurance products tailored to meet the needs of the senior citizens. These products include comprehensive and collision coverage, medical payments coverage, bodily injury liability, property damage liability, uninsured motorist bodily injury, and uninsured motorist property damage.

One of their most notable offerings is the Lifetime Continuation Agreement, which guarantees that your policy will not be dropped as long as certain conditions are met, such as maintaining a valid driver’s license and paying premiums on time. This seems like a significant advantage, especially for seniors who may worry about losing their car insurance as they age.

aarp membership tenure
Photo Credit: Medallion Media Group

The Hartford also offers RecoverCare, a unique service under AARP’s auto insurance policy. This coverage provides assistance with daily tasks that you may be unable to perform after a car accident, like house cleaning, lawn maintenance, meal prep, transportation, and even dog walking.

However, despite these beneficial features, a closer look at customer reviews on BBB and Trustpilot reveals a different story. Many customers have reported problems with claims processing, including delays and outright denials for unclear reasons. This is reminiscent of the plot in the movie ‘Catch 22’, where a no-win situation is created by bureaucratic rules – an apt metaphor for the frustrating situations some customers find themselves in.

AARP and The Hartford also offer a program called the AARP Auto Insurance Program. While the program is promoted as offering lower rates and superior benefits, some customers have questioned whether these benefits are worth the higher premiums. This skepticism is backed up by numerous complaints about sudden and steep premium increases, even for customers with clean driving records.

Moreover, while AARP promotes its products as being designed for seniors, many of the benefits can be found in standard policies from other insurers, often at lower rates. This has led some customers to question the true value of AARP’s car insurance products.

In the end, although AARP Insurance’s products may initially appear appealing, the customer reviews and company practices suggest that what’s promised may not always be what’s delivered. Like a car with a shiny exterior and questionable engine reliability, AARP Insurance products may not live up to the hype. This highlights the importance of thoroughly researching and comparing insurance products before making a decision.

AARP Insurance: Risks and Controversies

AARP Insurance, while reputable for its senior-focused mission, has been on the receiving end of numerous controversies and complaints. The company’s journey has been akin to a gut-wrenching action movie, laden with sudden plot twists and unexpected turns.

A primary concern among customers revolves around the transparency of AARP Insurance policies. Many have reported experiencing unexpected rate increases that are not clearly communicated. Customers claim that they were not adequately informed about these changes until they received their bills, much like a sudden twist in a thriller movie that leaves the audience gasping in surprise.

medicare advantage plans
Photo Credit: Medallion Media Group

Moreover, there have been significant complaints about AARP Insurance’s customer service and claims handling. Customers frequently report unhelpful customer service representatives and slow response times, reminiscent of a frustrating, drawn-out movie plot. Some have even reported claims being denied without a clear explanation, highlighting a potential risk in dealing with the company.

One of the most striking controversies involved a congressional investigation into AARP’s insurance practices in 2008. The investigation was triggered by concerns that AARP was acting more like an insurance company than an advocacy group for the elderly. The association’s significant earnings from royalties and fees from insurance policies sold to its members were scrutinized, creating a public relations nightmare for the company.

In a more recent controversy, AARP was sued by its members in 2016 for allegedly violating its fiduciary duty. The lawsuits claimed that AARP, despite presenting itself as an advocate for seniors, was receiving undisclosed commissions from insurers. These controversies have led to a questioning of AARP’s integrity and value proposition.

In an effort to gauge reader opinion on these issues, we conducted a survey, which revealed a high level of skepticism towards AARP Insurance. A significant number of respondents reported feeling uncertain about the company’s practices, echoing the overarching themes of controversy and mistrust.

Have you felt misled by AARP Insurance service descriptions?

In conclusion, it’s clear that AARP Insurance’s journey has been fraught with challenges, doubts, and controversies. Much like a suspenseful movie, the company’s trajectory has kept its audience on tenterhooks, wondering what the next scene will reveal. As always, the takeaway for consumers is to proceed with caution and do their due diligence before committing to an insurance policy.

Pros and Cons

When we assess the pros and cons of AARP Insurance, there arises a dichotomy between customer expectations and actual experiences. On paper, AARP Insurance offers many advantages for senior drivers, but real-life experiences and industry analysis reveal a different story.

Let’s start with the advantages. AARP Insurance offers policies specifically tailored for senior drivers, unlike many other insurers. They offer lifetime renewability and new car replacement, both of which are appealing features for their target demographic. AARP also provides RecoverCare, which helps cover costs for daily tasks if you’re injured in an accident, a feature not commonly found in the standard policies of many insurers.

However, when we contrast these benefits with the experiences reported by many customers, a murkier picture emerges. Complaints about AARP Insurance mainly revolve around sudden premium increases, poor customer service, and difficulty in claims processing.

aarp members
Photo Credit: Medallion Media Group

Moreover, when compared to well-respected companies like GEICO and State Farm, AARP Insurance seems to fall short in several areas. For instance, its customer service and responsiveness are often criticized, whereas GEICO and State Farm generally receive positive reviews for their customer service.

Looking at other well-known companies with mixed reviews, such as Progressive and Liberty Mutual, AARP Insurance doesn’t fare any better. While Progressive and Liberty Mutual have faced criticism for their claims process and customer service respectively, they have also been praised for their competitive rates and comprehensive coverage options. In contrast, AARP Insurance doesn’t seem to offer the same balance of strengths and weaknesses, with customer grievances largely overshadowing its benefits.

In conclusion, while AARP Insurance does have its merits, they seem to be outweighed by significant cons. The company, much like a protagonist in a film noir, promises much but often fails to deliver, leaving customers feeling disappointed and betrayed. It’s a stark reminder that all that glitters is not gold and that consumers need to dig deeper to uncover the true nature of any insurance offering.

Again, we recommend using a car insurance comparison chart to assess the pros and cons of different insurers, including AARP Insurance, before making a decision. Doing so will ensure that you’re picking a company that genuinely meets your needs and doesn’t just offer empty promises. In the world of insurance, skepticism is a valuable tool, and thorough research is the key to finding the right provider.


In conclusion, our critical review of AARP Insurance paints a picture that’s far from perfect. While the company does offer a range of car insurance products aimed at senior citizens, numerous issues relating to premium hikes, customer service, claims handling, and transparency cast a cloud of skepticism and caution.

This reflection of AARP Insurance is akin to the climactic scene in the movie “Inception.” Just when you think you’ve grasped the plot, a twist introduces new doubts and leaves you questioning the reality you thought you knew. It’s a reminder that when choosing an insurance provider, one must dig deeper, past the surface, to reveal the true nature of the company.

But the story doesn’t have to end with skepticism and disappointment. There are other insurance companies out there that have consistently received positive reviews for their transparency, customer service, and value for money. We encourage readers to explore these options and compare them against AARP Insurance to make an informed decision.

In the end, the choice of car insurance is a highly personal one, determined not just by the company’s offerings but also by its alignment with the customer’s needs and expectations. This is where our car insurance comparison chart comes in handy. This tool, much like the spinning top in “Inception,” can help you distinguish between reality and illusion when it comes to choosing the right insurance provider.

As we wrap up this critical review of AARP Insurance, we urge readers to remember that insurance is more than just about rates and benefits. It’s about trust, transparency, and the assurance that when you need it the most, your insurance provider will have your back.

So before you decide to take the plunge with AARP Insurance or any other provider, don’t forget to do your homework. Because when it comes to car insurance, much like the plot of a suspenseful movie, it’s the details that make all the difference.


  1. What exactly is AARP Insurance? AARP Insurance is a collection of insurance products offered by the American Association of Retired Persons (AARP), in partnership with insurance companies like The Hartford and UnitedHealthcare. AARP itself is not an insurer but lends its branding to these companies, and it’s important to note that these insurers are not necessarily the best or most affordable on the market.
  2. Do I have to be an AARP member to purchase AARP Insurance? Yes, in order to purchase an insurance policy branded by AARP, one must be a member of AARP. However, this also means paying an additional annual membership fee on top of insurance premiums.
  3. Does AARP Insurance offer the best rates for seniors? Despite the common perception, AARP Insurance does not necessarily offer the best rates for seniors. While their association with AARP may suggest specialization in senior coverage, it’s always wise to compare rates from multiple providers to ensure you’re getting the best deal.
  4. Are there any exclusive benefits for using AARP Insurance? While AARP does tout certain benefits like recover care, new car replacement, and lifetime renewability, it’s critical to remember that other insurance companies may provide similar, if not better, benefits. Each of these should be closely scrutinized and compared to others in the market.
  5. Is AARP Insurance financially stable? While AARP itself is not an insurer, the companies it partners with, such as The Hartford and UnitedHealthcare, are generally considered financially stable. However, customers should independently research these companies to confirm their stability and ability to pay claims.
  6. Does AARP Insurance offer a wide selection of insurance policies? Although AARP Insurance offers a variety of insurance types such as auto, home, and life coverage, the specific offerings can be limited in comparison to other insurers. Additionally, the policies are designed with seniors in mind and may not cater to the diverse needs of other age demographics.
  7. How is the customer service for AARP Insurance? The customer service experience with AARP Insurance can vary significantly, as it depends largely on the specific partner insurance company. Some customers report positive experiences, while others voice dissatisfaction with claim handling and response times.
  8. Does AARP Insurance offer discounts? Yes, AARP Insurance does offer discounts, but they may not be as numerous or as substantial as those offered by other insurance providers. Moreover, the application of these discounts can sometimes be complex and conditional.
  9. Is the AARP Insurance claims process straightforward? The claims process can differ greatly depending on the specific insurance company that underwrites the AARP-branded policy. Some customers have found it to be straightforward, while others have reported difficulties and delays in claim resolutions.
  10. Is AARP Insurance really worth it? Deciding if AARP Insurance is worth it ultimately comes down to individual needs and circumstances. It may offer peace of mind to some consumers due to AARP’s brand recognition, but it’s advised to thoroughly research and compare before committing, as there may be other options that provide better coverage at more competitive rates.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *