American Family Insurance Review: Is It Really As Good As It Sounds?

american family

Disclosure: We receive advertising revenue from some partners. Learn More


American Family Insurance is a familiar name in the car insurance industry, but beneath its friendly façade, the company has faced mounting skepticism and controversy eerily similar to the debt consolidation industry’s current trials. As we pry open its operations, this review is set to consider multiple angles, from customer testimonials to reviews on platforms such as the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and Trustpilot.

american family insurance group

For years, American Family Insurance has promised its clients a safe haven for their vehicles. However, the swelling wave of customer complaints and litigations flags a need for caution. Like a well-scripted drama, this company’s tale starts on high notes, but as the plot unfolds, it reveals a tale that might be reason enough for potential clients to think twice.

Just as critics question the integrity of the debt consolidation industry, so too does American Family Insurance face scrutiny, particularly within online review forums. On Trustpilot and BBB, consumers voice concerns about the company’s lackluster service, claims handling, and billing practices. These platforms, which serve to protect consumer interests, have recorded mixed to negative reviews about the company, prompting the need for potential clients to delve deeper into the company’s history, products, and practices before making a decision.

In light of this, our review will illuminate the lesser-known aspects of American Family Insurance and help you make an informed choice. Just as the debt consolidation industry faces a sea of skeptics, so too must American Family Insurance weather the storm of wary policyholders. Let this review be your beacon, guiding you towards an informed choice in your search for car insurance.

Company Background

American Family Insurance, also known as AmFam, is not a new player in the insurance game. Established in 1927 as Farmers Mutual Automobile Insurance Company, it has been serving the American population for over 90 years. The company rebranded as American Family Insurance in 1963 and has since expanded its operations nationwide.

Despite its longevity, the company is not without controversies. There are numerous instances and testimonies that cast doubt on the company’s practices and raise eyebrows at their claims. For instance, a case study involving a policyholder named John, whose claim was denied due to a fine print in his contract, raised questions about the company’s policy transparency.

Are you overpaying for car insurance?

Discover the

Rates as low as $29/month

This particular case echoes elements of the movie “John Q,” where the protagonist, played by Denzel Washington, battles a healthcare system and insurance company that refuses to cover his son’s heart transplant. Like John Q, many American Family policyholders feel ignored, mistreated, and betrayed by the company’s apparent disregard for their claims.

American Family Insurance Review: Is It Really As Good As It Sounds? 1
Photo Credit: Medallion Media Group

Moreover, several lawsuits have been filed against American Family. These legal battles usually involve allegations of bad faith, where the company is accused of not investigating claims properly or failing to settle claims fairly and promptly.

The company’s reputation has taken a hit due to such practices. On platforms like BBB and Trustpilot, American Family Insurance has received mixed to negative reviews. Consumers often complain about poor customer service, delayed claim settlements, and unfair premium hikes.

In light of these concerns, it’s crucial that potential policyholders thoroughly review any insurance contract and understand the company’s claims process before signing up. Just as the movie “John Q” shed light on the dark side of the healthcare insurance industry, this review seeks to highlight the potential pitfalls of dealing with American Family Insurance.


American Family Insurance offers a broad spectrum of auto insurance coverages, including but not limited to liability, collision, comprehensive, medical expense, personal injury protection, and uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage. While the company boasts a wide array of coverages, the value and utility of these products come under scrutiny due to the negative reviews and complaints lodged against them.

One striking issue is the lack of clarity and transparency in the terms and conditions of their policies. The company’s policies are sometimes described as confusing, with customers complaining about hidden clauses and fee structures. This can be illustrated through a quick quiz: Do you know what American Family’s underinsured motorist coverage entails, or how it calculates its deductible for collision coverage? If you’re like most people, you might struggle to answer these questions accurately.

Moreover, testimonials from customers underscore these issues. Unresolved claims, denied coverage, and unexpected premium hikes feature prominently in reviews on BBB and Trustpilot. Some customers have noted that the company is quick to collect premiums but slow to process claims, resulting in financial hardship for policyholders.

Moreover, American Family’s customer service has been a bone of contention for many policyholders. Poor communication, slow responsiveness, and a lack of empathy are common complaints. Despite the company’s assertion of being a “family”, many customers report feeling undervalued and neglected once they sign up.

In light of these issues, potential customers are advised to exercise due diligence before opting for an auto insurance policy with American Family. It is essential to understand fully what the policy covers, the exclusions, the process for filing claims, and the potential for rate increases. As always, it is prudent to seek advice from professionals or use comparison tools to ensure you’re getting the best deal for your coverage needs.

American Family: Risks and Controversies

American Family Insurance, while a longstanding player in the insurance industry, has a history of complaints and controversies that cannot be ignored. From lawsuits lodged against them to a wide array of customer complaints, the company comes with its fair share of risks.

Perhaps most notable are the numerous complaints filed against American Family with the Better Business Bureau. Customers have voiced dissatisfaction with the company’s claim handling processes, accusing them of slow responses, poor communication, and unjust denials of claims. These issues paint a picture of a company that may be more interested in collecting premiums than providing reliable coverage.

American Family Insurance Review: Is It Really As Good As It Sounds? 2
Photo Credit: Medallion Media Group

In addition to customer grievances, American Family has also faced legal challenges. The company has been the defendant in several lawsuits alleging bad faith, an accusation that suggests they may not be acting in the best interests of their policyholders. Such cases have resulted in significant settlements and further tarnished the company’s reputation.

To gauge reader opinion on these issues, we conducted a survey asking participants about their experiences and perceptions of American Family. The preliminary results are concerning, with a majority expressing skepticism about the company’s practices and reliability.

Controversies like these serve to highlight the risks associated with choosing American Family as your insurance provider. As with any insurance company, it’s crucial to do your research before committing. Read reviews, understand the terms of your policy, and make sure you feel comfortable with how your provider handles claims. Remember, an insurance policy is supposed to provide peace of mind, not add to your stress.

Pros and Cons

There’s no denying that American Family Insurance has a few positives in its favor, as reported by some users. Some of the pros include a broad range of coverage options and available discounts. However, when weighed against industry benchmarks and competitor offerings, the cons seem to tip the balance unfavorably.


  • Broad coverage options: From comprehensive to collision coverage, American Family offers a variety of insurance products that cater to diverse customer needs.
  • Available discounts: The company offers several discounts, including multi-product, defensive driver, and good student discounts, which can help to lower premium costs.


  • Poor customer service: One of the most common complaints against American Family is its poor customer service. These complaints range from lack of communication to slow claim processing.
  • Unexplained rate hikes: Another significant issue reported by policyholders is the unexpected and unexplained increase in insurance premiums.
  • Denial of claims: Numerous customers have reported unfair denial of claims, often due to obscure clauses in the policy.

When compared to established and well-respected companies like State Farm and Allstate, American Family seems to fall short. State Farm, for instance, is known for its exceptional customer service and fast claim processing, while Allstate receives high marks for its comprehensive coverage options and transparent pricing.

Even when juxtaposed with companies that have mixed reviews, like Progressive and Geico, American Family’s standing appears precarious. While Progressive has received complaints about its claim handling process, it still outranks American Family in customer satisfaction. Similarly, Geico, despite some negative reviews, is praised for its competitive rates and robust mobile app.

In conclusion, while American Family has some advantages, the negatives appear to outweigh the positives. It’s crucial for potential customers to thoroughly investigate and weigh their options before choosing an insurance provider.


In conclusion, American Family Insurance’s reputation in the car insurance industry is questionable. Despite a broad array of coverage options and available discounts, the company has faced numerous complaints and legal battles that cannot be overlooked.

Poor customer service, unexplained rate hikes, and unfair denial of claims are just some of the issues customers have reported. Compared unfavorably with industry benchmarks like State Farm and Allstate, and even against companies with mixed reviews like Progressive and Geico, American Family Insurance’s pitfalls are clear.

The company’s practices and the controversies surrounding it underscore the importance of thorough research and careful consideration when choosing an insurance provider. Just like Michael Corleone in “The Godfather” who says, “It’s not personal, it’s strictly business,” insurance is a business, and as such, it’s imperative to ensure you’re getting the best deal possible.

To that end, we encourage you to do further research using our car insurance comparison chart before making your final decision. This tool allows you to compare policies, prices, and customer reviews from various companies, helping you make the best choice for your unique needs.

In the end, just like in any good film, the choice is yours to make. Choose wisely, and remember, it’s not just about finding the best rates, but also about securing reliable coverage and peace of mind. Consider the words of “Ferris Bueller’s Day Off,” “Life moves pretty fast. If you don’t stop and look around once in a while, you could miss it.” Don’t rush your decision, take your time, and choose the insurance that best fits your needs.

American Family Insurance Review: Is It Really As Good As It Sounds? 3


  1. What kind of insurance policies does American Family Insurance offer? American Family Insurance provides a variety of insurance policies, ranging from home, auto, life, business to farm and ranch insurance. However, the coverage options may vary by state and it is advisable to carefully review the terms and conditions of each policy before purchasing.
  2. Is American Family Insurance affordable compared to other insurance companies? Cost is relative and can vary greatly based on individual circumstances. While some customers find American Family Insurance affordable, others have reported higher rates compared to other insurance providers. It’s recommended to obtain quotes from multiple companies to ensure the best price for the coverage needed.
  3. What is the customer satisfaction rating for American Family Insurance? While some customers report satisfactory experiences with American Family Insurance, the company has mixed reviews. Complaints often focus on claim denials and rate increases. It is crucial to do thorough research and consider customer reviews before deciding to purchase an insurance policy.
  4. How responsive is American Family Insurance when it comes to claims? The responsiveness of American Family Insurance, specifically in relation to claim processing, has been a point of contention for some policyholders. There have been reports of delays in claim processing and unsatisfactory communication during the process.
  5. Does American Family Insurance offer comprehensive coverage? American Family Insurance claims to offer comprehensive coverage, but the specifics can depend on the individual policy. Some customers have reported exclusions and limitations not initially made clear. It is important for prospective policyholders to thoroughly understand what their policy covers and what is excluded.
  6. Does American Family Insurance have a strong financial rating? While American Family Insurance holds an “A” rating from AM Best, indicating a strong ability to meet their ongoing insurance obligations, it’s always wise to consider financial stability as just one aspect when choosing an insurance provider.
  7. What has been reported about the customer service of American Family Insurance? American Family Insurance has received mixed reviews regarding customer service. Some customers have reported difficulty in reaching representatives, while others have praised the company’s customer service. Potential customers should consider this variability when choosing an insurance provider.
  8. How easy is it to receive a quote from American Family Insurance? Receiving a quote from American Family Insurance is generally straightforward and can be accomplished online or via phone. However, some customers have reported discrepancies between initial quotes and final rates.
  9. Does American Family Insurance offer any discounts? Yes, American Family Insurance does offer a variety of discounts. However, the criteria to qualify for these discounts can be quite specific, and not everyone may be eligible. Customers are encouraged to inquire about any potential discounts and how they can qualify.
  10. How transparent is American Family Insurance with their policies and services? Transparency seems to be a concern with American Family Insurance, as some customers have reported unexpected policy changes and rate increases. Prospective policyholders are advised to carefully review all policy details and ask for clarification on any points of confusion.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *