Chubb Car Insurance Review: Is it Really as Great as It Sounds?


Disclosure: We receive advertising revenue from some partners. Learn More


Chubb Car Insurance, a subsidiary of the global insurance giant Chubb Limited, undoubtedly holds a prominent position in the auto insurance market. With an illustrious history that dates back to the 19th century, the company would appear to be a trustworthy choice. However, in an industry that has recently been marred by skepticism and controversy, it’s essential to ask: does Chubb Car Insurance truly deliver on its promises?

auto coverage chubb homeowners insurance

When we turn our gaze to the popular review platforms BBB and Trustpilot, the trustworthiness of Chubb Car Insurance becomes questionable. The company has earned a score of 1.31 out of 5 stars on BBB, and a less than impressive 2.6 on Trustpilot. Complaints around customer service and claim handling are prevalent, suggesting that the experience for some customers is far from ideal.

But before diving headlong into customer reviews, it’s pivotal to have a fair understanding of Chubb Car Insurance. What is the company’s history? What services do they offer? How have they responded to the risks and controversies in their past? And, most importantly, how do they stack up against their competitors? In the following sections, we will critically review these aspects and more to help you make an informed decision. The auto insurance market isn’t as straightforward as it seems, and just like the movie “The Italian Job,” you may find yourself amidst a twist you didn’t see coming.

Company Background

Chubb Car Insurance traces its roots back to 1882, making it one of the oldest insurance companies in the United States. Originally founded as a marine underwriting business by Thomas Caldecot Chubb and his son Percy, the company has withstood the test of time, evolving and expanding its product line to cater to a wide array of customer needs.

chubb auto insurance chubb auto insurance review

Despite its longevity and strong foundation, Chubb Car Insurance’s reputation has been marred by several criticisms and controversies. Customers have frequently expressed dissatisfaction over claim denial and poor customer service. This tarnished customer perception mirrors a storyline from the 2004 film “Crash”, where the insurance company is portrayed as the antagonist due to its dubious practices, thus casting a shadow on the integrity of the insurer.

A notable case that brought Chubb Car Insurance under public scrutiny involved a policyholder whose claim was denied following a car accident. According to the customer’s testimony, Chubb cited a ‘wear and tear’ clause as a reason for the denial, which was not clearly communicated to the customer during the policy purchase. This incident, among many others, has led to a growing skepticism among consumers about Chubb’s transparency and claim handling process.

In recent years, Chubb has made attempts to improve its customer service and streamline its claim process. However, the question remains: Are these efforts sufficient to offset the negative customer experiences and regain trust?

Are you overpaying for car insurance?

Discover the

Rates as low as $29/month

While Chubb Car Insurance enjoys a strong market presence and offers a range of insurance products, the company’s history and performance underscore the need for customers to exercise caution and conduct thorough research before engaging with any car insurance firm. After all, as the popular adage goes, ‘Caveat Emptor’ – Let the buyer beware.


Chubb Car Insurance provides a broad spectrum of auto insurance products, but their Masterpiece Auto Preference (MAP) policy is the flagship offering. The MAP policy claims to offer an extensive range of coverages including, but not limited to, agreed value coverage, rental car coverage, and worldwide rental car coverage. Truly impressive on paper, but do these policies live up to the hype?

Customers’ experiences, reflected in reviews on BBB and Trustpilot, seem to challenge the validity of these claims. From complaints about the company’s refusal to cover damages to the lack of transparency in their policy terms, the promises made by Chubb Car Insurance appear to be falling short.

The agreed value coverage, a highlight of the MAP policy, assures policyholders that in the event of a total loss, they will receive the agreed amount without deduction. However, several customers have reported that Chubb denied their total loss claims, leaving them stranded with hefty repair bills.

Similarly, Chubb’s rental car coverage, which promises to cover the cost of a rental car for an unlimited period until the policyholder’s car is repaired, has also been called into question. Some customers have shared experiences where they were asked to return the rental car before their own vehicle was fixed.

These discrepancies between Chubb’s promises and its actual offerings have raised critical questions about the company’s product integrity and fairness. To help you evaluate the accuracy of these allegations, we’ve integrated a simple quiz below this section. Based on the facts presented and your knowledge, how much do you think Chubb Car Insurance’s products align with their advertising? Are their policies as comprehensive as they claim to be? This interactive element will help gauge public perception and evaluate the credibility of Chubb’s offerings.

In conclusion, while Chubb Car Insurance’s products seem appealing at first glance, the reality appears different. Potential customers need to tread carefully and ensure they fully understand the terms and conditions before investing in Chubb’s insurance products.

Chubb Car Insurance: Risks and Controversies

auto insurance discounts
Photo Credit: Medallion Media Group

Chubb Car Insurance hasn’t been immune to risks and controversies. Over the years, the company has faced a number of customer complaints and several lawsuits, posing a significant risk for potential customers.

One of the biggest controversies involving Chubb Car Insurance was a class-action lawsuit filed in 2019. Policyholders accused Chubb of implementing a systematic practice of denying Personal Injury Protection (PIP) claims without conducting a proper examination. They alleged the company arbitrarily denied or reduced claims, violating the terms of its own insurance contracts and numerous state laws.

Furthermore, customer complaints paint a grim picture of the company’s claim handling process. Many policyholders have registered dissatisfaction, citing delayed responses, refusal to cover legitimate claims, and poor customer service. They argue that these practices add stress to an already stressful situation of dealing with an accident or damage to their vehicle.

In another notable incident, Chubb was accused of denying a claim to a policyholder who had an accident while driving a rental car in Europe. The company cited an obscure clause in its policy, which stated that it only covers rental cars when the policyholder’s primary vehicle is being repaired. However, this clause was not clearly communicated to the policyholder at the time of purchasing the policy, raising questions about Chubb’s transparency.

These controversies and the frequent customer complaints suggest potential risks associated with choosing Chubb Car Insurance. It’s crucial for potential customers to thoroughly understand the terms of their insurance contract and be aware of these risks.

We encourage you to participate in a quick survey below to share your thoughts and experiences with Chubb Car Insurance. With your feedback, we can gauge public opinion about the company and better understand these issues. By shedding light on these controversies, we hope to help potential customers make a well-informed decision.

Pros and Cons

Choosing a car insurance policy is no small task, and it’s crucial to weigh the pros and cons before making a decision. When it comes to Chubb Car Insurance, there are several factors to consider.

On the pro side, Chubb offers a range of auto insurance products, including their Masterpiece Auto Preference (MAP) policy, comprehensive coverage options, and global coverage. Their policies are generally more comprehensive than those offered by standard car insurers. They also have a strong financial rating, which promises their ability to pay out claims.

However, the cons seem to overshadow these benefits. The primary concern among customers revolves around Chubb’s customer service and claim handling. Many customers report difficulty in reaching Chubb representatives and receiving timely responses to claims.

When compared to industry benchmarks like GEICO and State Farm, Chubb falls short. Both these companies are known for their robust customer service and swift claim handling. The discrepancy between Chubb and these well-respected providers is concerning.

Even when compared to companies with mixed reviews like Progressive and Allstate, Chubb’s customer service and claim response issues are more prominent. These companies, while having their own set of customer complaints, do not seem to face the severe level of dissatisfaction that is associated with Chubb Car Insurance.

Here are some key pros and cons of Chubb Car Insurance:


  • Comprehensive coverage options
  • Strong financial rating
  • Global coverage


  • Poor customer service
  • Slow response to claims
  • Lack of transparency in policy terms
  • D- BBB Rating

While Chubb offers comprehensive coverage options, the lack of strong customer service and slow response times to claims can be a significant disadvantage for policyholders. If these are factors you consider important in an insurance provider, you might want to reconsider choosing Chubb Car Insurance. As with any insurance decision, it’s essential to do your research and choose a provider that best suits your needs.


Chubb Car Insurance, with its long-standing history and seemingly impressive coverage options, may appear to be a great choice at a cursory glance. However, a deeper dive into customer experiences and the company’s handling of various controversies paints a different picture.

Consumer reviews highlight a consistent theme of dissatisfaction with Chubb’s claim handling process and customer service. These complaints, coupled with the company’s involvement in legal issues, raise red flags about its reliability and commitment to its policyholders. It’s clear that the company has faced significant challenges in maintaining its reputation and trustworthiness in the auto insurance market.

insurance commissioners rental car reimbursement
Photo Credit: Medallion Media Group

When compared to industry benchmarks like GEICO and State Farm, Chubb Car Insurance’s shortcomings become even more apparent. Even companies like Progressive and Allstate, which have received mixed reviews, seem to outperform Chubb in crucial areas such as customer service and claim handling.

In conclusion, while Chubb Car Insurance provides extensive coverage options, the company’s questionable practices and lackluster customer service record make it a risky choice for potential policyholders. Before making a decision, it’s important to conduct thorough research and consider the experiences of other consumers.

As we conclude this review, remember the twists and turns of The Italian Job. Much like in the movie, things may not always be as they seem. It’s vital to look beyond the surface-level promises of car insurance providers and dig deeper to understand the true value they provide.

Click the link below to explore our car insurance comparison chart. This tool allows you to compare various insurance providers side by side, helping you make an informed decision that suits your specific needs. Remember, the more informed you are, the better the chances of choosing the right car insurance for you.


  1. What does Chubb car insurance actually cover? Chubb car insurance is typically comprehensive, offering liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage. It also covers medical payments and protection against uninsured motorists. However, there may be certain limitations and exclusions in their policies that potential customers should thoroughly review before purchasing.
  2. Does Chubb offer nationwide coverage? Chubb does not offer coverage in all states, which is a significant limitation for potential customers looking for nationwide coverage. Therefore, it’s critical for customers to verify if Chubb provides coverage in their specific state.
  3. How does Chubb determine its premium rates? Chubb calculates its premium rates based on several factors, including the driver’s age, driving history, location, and the make and model of the vehicle. However, some customers have reported that Chubb’s rates are significantly higher than average.
  4. Does Chubb insurance offer comprehensive and collision coverage? Yes, Chubb does provide comprehensive and collision coverage. However, this is not included in a basic auto insurance policy and must be purchased separately, which can significantly increase the cost.
  5. Are there any discount programs with Chubb car insurance? Chubb does offer a range of discounts, such as multi-car and safe driver discounts. However, some customers have reported that these discounts are not as competitive as those offered by other insurance providers.
  6. How reliable is Chubb’s claims process? There have been mixed reviews about the reliability of Chubb’s claims process. While some customers have had positive experiences, others have reported a lengthy and complicated claims process.
  7. Does Chubb offer quality customer service? The quality of Chubb’s customer service varies. Some customers have reported satisfactory experiences, while others have had issues with slow response times, unresolved disputes, and lack of effective communication.
  8. What is the cancellation policy of Chubb car insurance? Customers can cancel their Chubb car insurance policy at any time. However, a cancellation fee may apply, which could be a deterrent for some customers.
  9. Is there a grace period for late payments with Chubb car insurance? Chubb does offer a grace period for late payments, but the length of this period can vary depending on the policy. Customers should carefully review their policy to avoid potential late fees or policy cancellation.
  10. Does Chubb car insurance offer rental car coverage? Chubb does offer rental car coverage, but it may be limited. If a customer frequently rents cars, they should carefully review their policy and consider additional coverage if necessary.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *